Houdini Match Results and Rating

[gaard]

Conditions:

Ponder=off
4" per move which is roughly equivalent to CCRL 40/4 when hardware is accounted for, only time management is precluded.
Nalimov 3-4-5 EGTB's
Fast 345 Shredderbases
30 positions at 12 move deep repeated with colors switched.

Code: Select all

Rank Name                  Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini_x64_1CPU      109   27   26   360   69%   -18   36% 
   2 Deep Rybka 4 x64      106   27   26   360   68%   -18   36% 
   3 Stockfish-171-64-ja    44   26   26   360   58%    -7   39% 
   4 Naum 4.2               -6   26   26   360   48%     1   39% 
   5 Shredder 12           -45   26   27   360   43%     8   33% 
   6 Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96   27   27   360   34%    16   33% 
   7 Zappa Mexico II x64  -113   27   27   360   31%    19   33% 

Up next... endgame performance statistics including IvanHoe 63 with TripleBases.

[gaard]

Code: Select all

   1 Houdini_x64_1CPU      109 360.0 (247.0 : 113.0)
                                60.0 ( 31.0 :  29.0) Deep Rybka 4 x64      106
                                60.0 ( 38.5 :  21.5) Stockfish-171-64-ja    44
                                60.0 ( 41.0 :  19.0) Naum                   -6
                                60.0 ( 44.0 :  16.0) Ds12                  -45
                                60.0 ( 47.0 :  13.0) Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96
                                60.0 ( 45.5 :  14.5) Zappa Mexico II x64  -113
   2 Deep Rybka 4 x64      106 360.0 (244.5 : 115.5)
                                60.0 ( 29.0 :  31.0) Houdini_x64_1CPU      109
                                60.0 ( 39.0 :  21.0) Stockfish-171-64-ja    44
                                60.0 ( 42.5 :  17.5) Naum                   -6
                                60.0 ( 38.5 :  21.5) Ds12                  -45
                                60.0 ( 46.0 :  14.0) Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96
                                60.0 ( 49.5 :  10.5) Zappa Mexico II x64  -113
   3 Stockfish-171-64-ja    44 360.0 (207.5 : 152.5)
                                60.0 ( 21.5 :  38.5) Houdini_x64_1CPU      109
                                60.0 ( 21.0 :  39.0) Deep Rybka 4 x64      106
                                60.0 ( 34.5 :  25.5) Naum                   -6
                                60.0 ( 37.5 :  22.5) Ds12                  -45
                                60.0 ( 46.0 :  14.0) Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96
                                60.0 ( 47.0 :  13.0) Zappa Mexico II x64  -113
   4 Naum                   -6 360.0 (174.5 : 185.5)
                                60.0 ( 19.0 :  41.0) Houdini_x64_1CPU      109
                                60.0 ( 17.5 :  42.5) Deep Rybka 4 x64      106
                                60.0 ( 25.5 :  34.5) Stockfish-171-64-ja    44
                                60.0 ( 38.5 :  21.5) Ds12                  -45
                                60.0 ( 37.5 :  22.5) Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96
                                60.0 ( 36.5 :  23.5) Zappa Mexico II x64  -113
   5 Ds12                  -45 360.0 (153.0 : 207.0)
                                60.0 ( 16.0 :  44.0) Houdini_x64_1CPU      109
                                60.0 ( 21.5 :  38.5) Deep Rybka 4 x64      106
                                60.0 ( 22.5 :  37.5) Stockfish-171-64-ja    44
                                60.0 ( 21.5 :  38.5) Naum                   -6
                                60.0 ( 33.5 :  26.5) Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96
                                60.0 ( 38.0 :  22.0) Zappa Mexico II x64  -113
   6 Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96 360.0 (121.5 : 238.5)
                                60.0 ( 13.0 :  47.0) Houdini_x64_1CPU      109
                                60.0 ( 14.0 :  46.0) Deep Rybka 4 x64      106
                                60.0 ( 14.0 :  46.0) Stockfish-171-64-ja    44
                                60.0 ( 22.5 :  37.5) Naum                   -6
                                60.0 ( 26.5 :  33.5) Ds12                  -45
                                60.0 ( 31.5 :  28.5) Zappa Mexico II x64  -113
   7 Zappa Mexico II x64  -113 360.0 (112.0 : 248.0)
                                60.0 ( 14.5 :  45.5) Houdini_x64_1CPU      109
                                60.0 ( 10.5 :  49.5) Deep Rybka 4 x64      106
                                60.0 ( 13.0 :  47.0) Stockfish-171-64-ja    44
                                60.0 ( 23.5 :  36.5) Naum                   -6
                                60.0 ( 22.0 :  38.0) Ds12                  -45
                                60.0 ( 28.5 :  31.5) Spark-0.4-win64-mp    -96

[gaard]

To get a better idea of the scaling of Houdini 1.01, I am playing it against the same 6 opponents with the same condition. Initial results are not promising, but there are still many more games to be played.

Could anybody guess how H1.01 lost this one to DR4? Tablebases would have helped somewhat, but I think the game was lost before they would come into play.

[Event "HOUD4S"]
[Site "MARTIN-EKOEWKAL"]
[Date "2010.06.10"]
[Round "12"]
[White "Deep Rybka 4 x64"]
[Black "Houdini_x64_4CPU 4CPU"]
[Result "1-0"]
[BlackElo "2200"]
[ECO "C48"]
[Opening "Four Knights"]
[Time "14:05:19"]
[Variation "Rubinstein, 5.Ba4 Nxf3+"]
[WhiteElo "2200"]
[TimeControl "0+4"]
[Termination "adjudication"]
[PlyCount "165"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "human"]

1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Nc3 Nf6 4. Bb5 Nd4 5. Ba4 c6 6. d3 Nxf3+ 7. Qxf3 d6
8. O-O Be7 9. Nd5 h6 10. c3 Be6 11. Nxe7 Qxe7 12. Qe2 g5 13. Bc2 {+0.38/11
4} O-O-O {-0.33/16 4} 14. a4 {+0.42/13 4} Kb8 {-0.33/16 4} 15. b4 {+0.47/13
4} Nd7 {-0.34/17 4} 16. a5 {+0.52/13 3} Nf8 {-0.36/18 4} 17. a6 {+0.57/12
4} b6 {-0.28/16 4} 18. Ba4 {+0.54/13 3} Rc8 {-0.18/17 4} 19. c4 {+0.41/12
4} Ng6 {-0.18/16 4} 20. Bb2 {+0.43/12 4} f6 {-0.15/16 4} 21. Qe3 {+0.33/11
4} h5 {-0.10/16 4} 22. c5 {+0.40/14 4} b5 {-0.10/19 4} 23. Bc2 {+0.39/15 4}
dxc5 {-0.07/19 4} 24. bxc5 {+0.39/15 4} Nf4 {-0.06/19 4} 25. Rfd1 {+0.36/13
4} Rcd8 {-0.10/17 4} 26. Kh1 {+0.37/13 3} h4 {-0.05/17 4} 27. d4 {+0.33/13
4} Bc8 {-0.05/15 4} 28. dxe5 {+0.71/10 4} fxe5 {-0.16/18 4} 29. Qc3
{+0.59/11 4} Rxd1+ {-0.21/19 4} 30. Rxd1 {+0.73/11 4} Re8 {-0.15/20 4} 31.
Rd6 {+0.55/12 4} Bxa6 {-0.21/18 4} 32. Rxc6 {+0.77/14 4} Qb7 {-0.24/19 4}
33. Rh6 {+1.05/12 4} b4 {-0.24/18 4} 34. Qxe5+ {+0.90/13 4} Rxe5 {-0.22/20
4} 35. Bxe5+ {+0.75/14 4} Kc8 {-0.21/20 4} 36. c6 {+0.83/15 4} Qe7
{-0.19/19 4} 37. Rh8+ {+0.85/13 4} Qd8 {-0.18/19 4} 38. Rxd8+ {+0.85/13 3}
Kxd8 {-0.16/18 4} 39. Bf6+ {+0.88/15 4} Kc7 {-0.10/19 4} 40. Bxg5 {+0.88/14
3} Nd3 {-0.12/19 4} 41. Bxh4 {+0.89/14 4} Bc4 {-0.15/17 4} 42. Ba4
{+0.93/15 4} Nb2 {0.00/19 4} 43. Bg3+ {+0.81/15 4} Kc8 {0.00/24 4} 44. Bc2
{+0.24/16 4} Bd3 {0.00/22 4} 45. Bb3 {+0.49/16 4} Bc4 {0.00/21 4} 46. Be5
{+0.53/17 4} Bxb3 {-0.14/19 4} 47. Bxb2 {+0.65/17 3} Kc7 {-0.19/18 4} 48.
h4 {+0.91/14 4} a5 {-0.16/18 4} 49. Bc1 {+1.23/14 4} Kxc6 {-0.22/16 4} 50.
h5 {+1.29/15 4} a4 {-0.69/15 4} 51. h6 {+2.31/13 4} Bg8 {-0.96/17 4} 52. f4
{+2.43/14 4} a3 {-1.03/15 4} 53. g4 {+2.48/15 4} Kb5 {-0.98/17 4} 54. g5
{+2.60/15 4} Ka4 {-0.52/19 4} 55. g6 {+2.71/14 4} b3 {-0.59/20 4} 56. Bxa3
{+2.83/15 4} Kxa3 {-0.70/22 4} 57. h7 {+2.83/15 4} Bxh7 {-0.74/23 4} 58.
gxh7 {+2.98/15 4} b2 {-0.74/23 4} 59. h8=Q {+2.98/15 4} b1=Q+ {-0.74/23 4}
60. Kh2 {+2.98/15 4} Qc2+ {-0.81/22 4} 61. Kg3 {+3.08/15 4} Qxe4 {-0.81/22
4} 62. Qe5 {+M55/59 1} Qd3+ {-0.81/23 4} 63. Kh4 {+M54/59 1} Qh7+ {-0.81/23
4} 64. Kg5 {+M53/59 1} Qg8+ {-0.81/23 4} 65. Kf6 {+M52/59 1} Qf8+ {-0.84/22
4} 66. Kg6 {+M51/59 1} Qg8+ {-0.92/22 4} 67. Qg7 {+M50/59 1} Qe8+ {-0.91/21
4} 68. Qf7 {+M49/59 1} Qc6+ {-1.05/21 4} 69. Qf6 {+M48/59 1} Qg2+ {-1.19/20
4} 70. Kf7 {+M47/59 1} Kb3 {-1.31/21 4} 71. Qb6+ {+M46/59 1} Kc3 {-1.31/21
4} 72. f5 {+M45/59 1} Qd5+ {-1.40/22 4} 73. Qe6 {+M44/59 1} Qb7+ {-1.40/22
4} 74. Kf8 {+M43/59 1} Qa8+ {-1.52/20 4} 75. Ke7 {+M42/59 1} Qa7+ {-1.52/22
4} 76. Qd7 {+M40/59 1} Qc5+ {-1.60/21 4} 77. Kd8 {+M38/59 1} Kb2 {-1.67/19
4} 78. Qb7+ {+M36/59 1} Ka2 {-2.11/18 3} 79. Qa6+ {+M35/59 1} Kb3 {-3.21/19
4} 80. f6 {+M34/59 1} Qd5+ {-3.22/21 4} 81. Kc7 {+M31/59 1} Qh5 {-3.22/21
4} 82. Qe6+ {+M29/59 1} Ka3 {-3.53/22 4} 83. f7 {+M28/59 1 1-0 User
Adjudication} 1-0

[notyetagm]

Houdini is so great.

Why buy Rybka 4 when Houdini 1.01 is just as strong and free?

[Aloha]

Houdini wins after only 44 moves by the popular defense Najdorf/B90...
Respect!




[Event "?"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2010.06.12"]
[Round "6"]
[White "Houdini 1.01"]
[Black "Deep Rybka 4"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B90"]
[PlyCount "64"]
[EventDate "2010.??.??"]
[TimeControl "300+50"]
[WhiteClock "0:00:35"]
[BlackClock "0:00:31"]

{[%t Long] Schwarz gibt auf. (1--0) [%t bLon] Eröffnungsbuch: E2E-12moves} 1.
e4 {0.11/1 0 [%clko 0:04:00]} c5 {0.29/1 0 [%clko 0:04:03]} 2. Nf3 {0.29/1 0
[%clko 0:04:02]} d6 {0.29/1 0 [%clko 0:04:05]} 3. d4 {0.22/1 0 [%clko 0:04:05]}
cxd4 {0.22/1 0 [%clko 0:04:08]} 4. Nxd4 {0.22/1 0 [%clko 0:04:08]} Nf6 {0.22/1
0 [%clko 0:04:11]} 5. Nc3 {0.22/1 0 [%clko 0:04:11]} a6 {0.29/1 0 [%clko 0:04:
14]} 6. Be3 {0.26/1 0 [%clko 0:04:14]} e5 {0.52/1 0 [%clko 0:04:17]} 7. Nb3 {
0.52/1 0 [%clko 0:04:17]} Be6 {0.52/1 0 [%clko 0:04:20]} 8. f3 {0.22/1 0
[%clko 0:04:20]} Be7 {0.22/1 0 [%clko 0:04:23]} 9. Qd2 {0.15/1 0 [%clko 0:04:
23]} O-O {0.00/1 0 [%clko 0:04:26]} 10. O-O-O {0.00/1 0 [%clko 0:04:26]} Nbd7 {
0.00/1 0 [%clko 0:04:29]} 11. g4 {0.00/1 0 [%clko 0:04:29]} b5 {0.00/1 0
[%clko 0:04:32]} 12. g5 {0.00/1 0 [%clko 0:04:32]} Nh5 {0.00/1 0 [%clko 0:04:
35] Weiß ist aus dem Buch} 13. Kb1 {0.03/17 11 [%clko 0:04:00] Schwarz ist aus
dem Buch} Nb6 {0.19/13 11 [%clko 0:03:51]} 14. Nd5 {0.00/16 11 [%clko 0:03:51]}
Nxd5 {0.08/13 10 [%clko 0:03:43]} 15. exd5 {0.00/14 0 [%clko 0:03:44]} Bd7 {0.
08/13 14 [%clko 0:03:45]} 16. Rg1 {-0.01/16 11 [%clko 0:03:32]} Rc8 {0.07/13
14 [%clko 0:03:37]} 17. Bd3 {0.08/17 12 [%clko 0:03:23]} g6 {0.17/12 9 [%clko
0:03:29]} 18. f4 {0.05/16 6 [%clko 0:03:17]} exf4 {0.27/11 20 [%clko 0:03:25]}
19. Bxf4 {0.07/13 0 [%clko 0:03:00]} Nxf4 {0.33/12 14 [%clko 0:03:28]} 20. Qxf4
{0.12/16 2 [%clko 0:02:49]} Qb6 {0.33/12 10 [%clko 0:03:29]} 21. h4 {0.23/16
10 [%clko 0:02:42]} a5 {0.33/12 8 [%clko 0:03:22]} 22. Nd4 {0.25/15 7 [%clko 0:
02:37]} a4 {0.32/11 15 [%clko 0:03:18]} 23. h5 {0.88/15 48 [%clko 0:02:25]} Rc4
{1.07/10 24 [%clko 0:02:33]} 24. Bxc4 {0.90/13 9 [%clko 0:02:04]} bxc4 {1.09/
11 5 [%clko 0:02:27]} 25. c3 {1.26/15 25 [%clko 0:02:01]} a3 {1.37/10 8 [%clko
0:02:05]} 26. Rg2 {1.26/13 0 [%clko 0:01:57]} Qb7 {1.40/10 10 [%clko 0:02:08]}
27. Re2 {1.40/15 6 [%clko 0:01:50] e3 [%clk 0:01:38] [%clko 0:02:05] [%emt 0:
00:16] [%eval 179,10] Z0 [%clk 0:02:04] [%clko 0:01:38] [%emt 0:00:05] [%eval
141,14] Z0 [%clk 0:01:36] [%clko 0:02:04] [%emt 0:00:04] [%eval 191,12] Qxd6
[%clk 0:02:06] [%clko 0:01:36] [%emt 0:00:00] [%eval 141,13]} Bg4 {1.76/12 8
[%clko 0:02:06] Z0 [%clk 0:02:05] [%clko 0:01:30] [%emt 0:00:05] [%eval 139,16]
Re8 [%clk 0:01:27] [%clko 0:02:05] [%emt 0:00:07] [%eval 178,12]} 28. Rf2 {1.
54/16 8 [%clko 0:01:27]} Be6 {1.92/12 5 [%clko 0:01:58]} 29. dxe6 {1.54/14 0
[%clko 0:01:26]} Qe4+ {2.02/12 8 [%clko 0:02:01]} 30. Ka1 {1.71/16 8 [%clko 0:
01:21] Z0 [%clk 0:01:16] [%clko 0:01:58] [%emt 0:00:08] [%eval 202,13] Qxa3
[%clk 0:02:00] [%clko 0:01:16] [%emt 0:00:00] [%eval 171,15]} Qxe6 {2.02/12 8
[%clko 0:02:00] Qa5 [%clk 0:01:58] [%clko 0:01:10] [%emt 0:00:04] [%eval 176,
15]} 31. h6 {2.04/10 6 [%clko 0:01:58] a4 [%clk 0:01:55] [%clko 0:01:08] [%emt
0:00:06] [%eval 190,14] Z0 [%clk 0:01:00] [%clko 0:01:55] [%emt 0:00:10]
[%eval 240,10] Rff1 [%clk 0:01:51] [%clko 0:01:00] [%emt 0:00:07] [%eval 236,
14] Z0 [%clk 0:00:54] [%clko 0:01:51] [%emt 0:00:10] [%eval 240,10] Qb5 [%clk
0:01:50] [%clko 0:00:54] [%emt 0:00:04] [%eval 267,14]} Rc8 {2.68/9 13 [%clko
0:01:50] Rfe1 [%clk 0:01:47] [%clko 0:00:43] [%emt 0:00:05] [%eval 367,15] Qc6
[%clk 0:00:43] [%clko 0:01:47] [%emt 0:00:03] [%eval 371,10] Rd7 [%clk 0:01:50]
[%clko 0:00:43] [%emt 0:00:00] [%eval 367,13] Kf8 [%clk 0:00:42] [%clko 0:01:
50] [%emt 0:00:04] [%eval 398,10] Qb4 [%clk 0:01:52] [%clko 0:00:42] [%emt 0:
00:02] [%eval 394,14] Kg8 [%clk 0:00:37] [%clko 0:01:52] [%emt 0:00:08] [%eval
408,11] Rd6 [%clk 0:01:37] [%clko 0:00:37] [%emt 0:00:18] [%eval 602,16]} 32.
Qf3 {5.40/10 4 [%clko 0:01:37] Qb5 [%clk 0:01:40] [%clko 0:00:35] [%emt 0:00:
00] [%eval 602,15]} Rf8 {5.40/9 7 [%clko 0:01:40] Qxc4+ [%clk 0:01:41] [%clko
0:00:31] [%emt 0:00:02] [%eval 658,14]} 1-0

[robbolito]

AMD-X6.x64 Blitz:10', Blitz:10' 0

Code: Select all

1   Deep Rybka 4 x64            3175  +5/-4/=21 51.67%   15.5/30
2   Houdini DEVEL-V2 x64 8_CPU  2890  +4/-5/=21 48.33%   14.5/30

[robbolito]

Qi7- 960 XP.x64, Blitz:10' 0

Code: Select all

1   Houdini DEVEL-V1 x64 8_CPU  3185  +6/-6/=18 50.00%   15.0/30  225.00
2   Deep Rybka 4 x64            3150  +6/-6/=18 50.00%   15.0/30  225.00

[robbolito]

Q9550-XP64, Blitz:10' 0

Code: Select all

1   Deep Rybka 4 x64            3185  +7/-4/=19 55.00%   16.5/30
2   Houdini DEVEL-V2 x64 8_CPU  3130  +4/-7/=19 45.00%   13.5/30

[robbolito]

AMD-X6.x64 Blitz:10', Blitz:10' 0

Code: Select all

                                      1234567890
1   Houdini DEVEL-V1 x64 8_CPU  3175  ½0½½½½½1½1   5.5/10
2   Deep Rybka 4 x64            3175  ½1½½½½½0½0   4.5/10

[robbolito]

Qi7- 960 XP.x64, Blitz:10' 0

Code: Select all

                                      1234567890
1   Deep Rybka 4 x64            3185   0½1½1½½½½½   5.5/10
2   Houdini DEVEL-V2 x64 8_CPU  3185   1½0½0½½½½½   4.5/10